Understanding Migration, Citizenship Challenges and Social InclusionNAME: FATIN WAHDAH BINTI ROSMIN NO MATRIC: BB25110054 COURSE CODE: BH30703 INSTITUTION: UMS
Citizenship and Legal Identity ChallengesEducation ChallengesHealthcare and Employment ChallengesSocial and Economic ImpactIntergenerational StatelessnessConclusion1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 TABLE OF CONTENTHistory of Migration in SabahMigration TrendsFactors Contributing to StatelessnessGovernment Policies and Existing EffortsRecommendations for the GovernmentRecommendations for the Communities and Organisatiom Introduction
Statelessness is an important social issue in Sabah because some individuals are not recognised as citizens by any country. Sabah's geographical location near the Philippines and Indonesia has contributed to long-term cross-border migration. During the 1970s, political conflict in southern Philippines caused many people to seek refuge in Sabah. Over time, some migrant families settled in the state and had children. However, incomplete birth records and difficulties proving nationality have placed some children at risk of statelessness (Mohd Afsur Khan & Fathil, 2020). This issue is important because legal identity can affect access to education, healthcare, employment and other basic services. Therefore, understanding statelessness is necessary to improve social inclusion and protect vulnerable communities (Loganathan et al., 2022). Introduction: Background of Statelessness in Sabah 1
Sabah has experienced migration for many years because of its geographical location near the Philippines and Indonesia. Before the formation of Malaysia in 1963, communities in the region already had connections through trade, family relationships and movement across coastal areas. During the 1970s, conflict in southern Philippines encouraged many people to seek safety in Sabah. At the same time, workers from Indonesia migrated to Sabah for employment in industries such as plantations, construction and services. These movements contributed to the growth of migrant communities and long-term settlement in Sabah (Loganathan et al., 2022; Allerton, 2025). History of Migration in Sabah 2
Migration Trends in Sabah Migration in Sabah involves different groups and reasons for movement. Three important patterns can be identified: Cross-border migration: People move between Sabah and neighbouring countries, particularly the Philippines and Indonesia. Labour migration: Migrant workers enter Sabah to find employment in plantations, agriculture, construction and services. Long-term settlement: Some migrant families have lived in Sabah for several generations, and their children may be born in the state. These patterns show that migration in Sabah is not only temporary movement. It also involves family life, employment and long-term settlement (Loganathan et al., 2022). 3
Political conflict: Conflict in neighbouring countries has forced some families to leave their homes and seek safety elsewhere. Economic migration: Some migrant families settle in Sabah for employment but face difficulties obtaining or maintaining official documents. Lack of birth registration: Children whose births are not properly registered may experience difficulties proving their identity. Incomplete family records: Missing documents and difficulties verifying parents' nationality can make citizenship applications more complicated. These factors do not automatically make someone stateless, but they can increase the risk of having an uncertain nationality (Mohd Afsur Khan & Fathil, 2020; Loganathan et al., 2022). Factors Contributing to Statelessness 4
Citizenship determines a person's legal membership in a country. In Malaysia, citizenship is governed by Part III of the Federal Constitution. Article 14 and the Second Schedule explain the conditions for acquiring citizenship by operation of law. Article 15A also allows the registration of individuals below 21 years old in special circumstances, subject to government approval. However, being born in Malaysia does not automatically mean that every child receives Malaysian citizenship. The child's circumstances and constitutional requirements must be considered. Missing documents can make the process of establishing nationality more difficult (Federal Constitution of Malaysia, 1957; Jabatan Pendaftaran Negara [ JPN], n.d.). Citizenship and Legal Identity Challenges 5
Education is one of the major challenges faced by stateless and undocumented children in Sabah. Children without recognised citizenship documents may face difficulties entering government schools. As a result, some depend on alternative learning centres established by communities, non-governmental organisations and other organisations. However, these centres may face limited funding, insufficient facilities and a lack of qualified teachers. Some children also experience transportation difficulties and financial problems. These barriers can affect their learning progress and future opportunities (Loganathan et al., 2022, 2023). Challenges in Accessing Education 6
Statelessness and uncertain legal identity can also affect access to healthcare and employment. Some stateless individuals face difficulties obtaining affordable medical services because they may be charged as non-citizens. For example, research involving the Bajau Laut community in Semporna highlights challenges in accessing basic healthcare services (How, 2024). Adults without recognised legal status may also experience difficulties entering formal employment. Some depend on informal work, which can expose them to low wages, insecure working conditions and exploitation. These challenges can affect their financial stability and family wellbeing (UN Malaysia, 2025). Healthcare and Employment Challenges 7
Statelessness creates challenges not only for individuals but also for society. People without recognised nationality may experience social exclusion, discrimination and limited opportunities. Their difficulties in accessing education and formal employment can reduce their chances of improving their living conditions. From an economic perspective, limited access to formal employment may prevent individuals from developing their skills and contributing fully to the economy. This can increase dependence on informal activities and create long-term social challenges. Therefore, addressing statelessness is important for promoting equality and inclusive development in Sabah (Mohd Afsur Khan & Fathil, 2020; UN Malaysia, 2025). However, being born in Malaysia does not automatically mean that every child receives Malaysian citizenship. The child's circumstances and constitutional requirements must be considered. Missing documents can make the process of establishing nationality more difficult (Federal Constitution of Malaysia, 1957; Jabatan Pendaftaran Negara [ JPN], n.d.). Social and Economic Impacts 8
Intergenerational statelessness occurs when problems involving nationality and legal identity continue from parents to their children. For example, parents who cannot prove their nationality may face difficulties registering their children's births or establishing their citizenship. As a result, children may grow up without clear legal recognition and face similar challenges when they become adults. However, statelessness is not automatically passed from one generation to another. A child's nationality depends on the relevant citizenship laws and individual circumstances. Early birth registration, proper documentation and accessible legal assistance are important to prevent this problem from continuing across generations (UNHCR, n.d.; Loganathan et al., 2022). Intergenerational Statelessness 9
The Malaysian government addresses citizenship and birth registration through the Federal Constitution and the National Registration Department ( JPN). JPN provides procedures for birth registration and citizenship applications, including applications under Article 15A for individuals below 21 years old in special circumstances. International organisations and community organisations also contribute through research, education support and assistance for vulnerable groups. For example, UNICEF and other organisations have highlighted the importance of children's legal identity and access to education. Although these efforts are important, documentation and citizenship issues remain complex and require continued cooperation between government agencies and communities ( JPN, n.d.; UN Malaysia, 2025). Government Policies and Existing Efforts 10
Improve birth registration: Provide mobile registration services to reach remote communities. Simplify application procedures: Make citizenship and documentation requirements easier to understand. Provide legal assistance: Help families understand their rights and complete applications. Strengthen cooperation: Improve coordination between JPN, local authorities and relevant organisations. Improve data collection: Conduct appropriate research to understand the different groups affected. These strategies can help improve legal identity and make administrative services more accessible (UN Malaysia, 2025; JPN, n.d.). Recommendations for the Government 11
Communities and non-governmental organisations also play an important role in addressing statelessness. First, they can organise awareness programmes to educate parents about the importance of birth registration and legal documents. Second, organisations can support children through alternative learning centres, educational materials and basic skills training. Third, community leaders can help families connect with relevant government agencies when they need assistance with documentation. Finally, society should avoid discrimination against people because of their nationality or documentation status. Cooperation between communities, organisations and government agencies can create a more inclusive environment for everyone (Loganathan et al., 2023; UN Malaysia, 2025). Recommendations for Communities and Organisations 12
In conclusion, statelessness in Sabah is a complex issue connected to historical migration, citizenship laws and difficulties with legal documentation. It affects individuals and families, particularly when they face barriers to education, healthcare, employment and social inclusion. Although the government and various organisations have introduced efforts to address these challenges, further improvements are still needed. Better birth registration, accessible legal assistance, educational support and stronger cooperation can help reduce the risk of statelessness. Ultimately, every individual should have the opportunity to establish their legal identity and access basic services. Addressing this issue is an important step towards a fairer and more inclusive society in Sabah. ConclusionMohd Afsur Khan, J. J., & Fathil, F. (2020). Stateless Filipino children in modern day Sabah: Issues of concern and responses of the state government. IIUM Journal of Human Sciences, 2(1), 55–63. https://doi.org/10.31436/ijohs.v2i1.146 Loganathan et al. (2022) – For legal identity, undocumented children and education challenges in Malaysia, including Sabah. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article? id=10.1371/journal.pone.0263404 Loganathan, T., Chan, Z. X., Hassan, F., Ong, Z. L., & Abdul Majid, H. (2022). Undocumented: An examination of legal identity and education provision for children in Malaysia. PLOS ONE, 17(2), e0263404. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0263404 UNICEF. (2026). Sabah Child Wellbeing Index: Study report. https://www.unicef.org/malaysia/reports/sabah-child-wellbeing-index Jabatan Pendaftaran Negara. (n.d.). Citizenship. https://www.jpn.gov.my/en/services/citizenship/ United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. (n.d.). Stateless people. https://www.unhcr.org/about-unhcr/who-we-protect/stateless-people 13
