Name: Lorenz Jefferson O. Ocampo Group Number / Class Section: Group 3 10E Date Submitted: Date 1. Topic Research & Moral Analysis Topic Title / Case Study: Death Penalty A. Issue Overview & Moral Question ● Background & Context: The death penalty, also called capital punishment, is when the government legally executes a person who has been found guilty of a serious crime. ● This topic is controversial because some people believe it gives justice to victims, while others believe that taking another person's life is not the right way to punish someone. ● In the Philippines, the death penalty was prohibited through Republic Act No. 9346 in 2006. Today, the debate continues because some people want it brought back, especially for serious crimes. ● ● ● Central Moral Question: Should the government bring back the death penalty for people who commit serious crimes, or should criminals receive other punishments that protect society while respecting human life? ● B. Arguments & Counterarguments: Justice for victims: Some people believe that criminals who commit extremely serious crimes deserve the strongest punishment. Crime prevention: Supporters believe that the death penalty might discourage people from committing serious crimes. Protection of society: Executing dangerous criminals permanently prevents them from harming people outside prison. Accountability: People should face serious consequences for the crimes they commit. Arguments & Counterarguments section

Perspective Core Reasoning / Arguments Key Evidence or Supporting Claims Supporting Arguments (Proponents) The death penalty gives severe punishment to people who commit extremely serious crimes ● 1. It provides punishment proportionate to extremely serious crimes. ● 2. It may give victims families a sense of justice. ● 3. It permanently prevents the convicted offender from committing another crime outside prison. ● Opposing Arguments (Counterarguments) Human life has dignity and should not be taken away as punishment. The justice system can make mistakes, and innocent people may be wrongly convicted. ● 1. Wrongful convictions can result in innocent people being punished. ● 2. Research has not established that the death penalty reduces murder rates. ● 3. Life imprisonment can protect society while allowing the possibility of rehabilitation. ● ● C. Catholic Church Teachings & Authoritative Sources: ● Official Church Stance: Draft the Church Teachings section by summarizing official Catholic

Church doctrine relevant to the issue using authoritative magisterial sources and citing official documents like papal encyclicals or the Catechism. [ ] Source Category Citation Key Quote / Principle & Relevance Sacred Scripture [Genesis 1:27] Every human being is created in the image and likeness of God. This reminds us that every person has dignity and worth. Catechism (CCC) [ CCC Paragraph 2267] The death penalty is inadmissible because it attacks the inviolability and dignity of the human person. Magisterial Document [Fratelli Tutti, Paragraphs 263–269] Pope Francis explains that the death penalty is unacceptable and that society can protect people without taking away the dignity and possibility of redemption of offenders. D. Moral Evaluation Analyze competing positions using core Catholic moral framework elements: ● Human Dignity (Imago Dei): When a person is created in the image and likeness of God. Even people who commit serious crimes still have human dignity. Summary of magisterial teaching on this issue.

Therefore, they should be punished fairly without taking away their right to life. ● Moral Object, Intention, & Circumstances: ● Moral Object:Taking the life of a convicted criminal as punishment ● Intention:To achieve justice, punish serious crimes, and protect society. ● Circumstances:The seriousness of the crime, the suffering of victims, the possibility of wrongful convictions, and the availability of other punishments. ● ● Key Moral Principles Applied: Sanctity of Life: Every human life is valuable and deserves respect. ● Common Good: The government must protect citizens and maintain peace and safety. ● Human Dignity: Criminals do not lose their dignity even after committing serious crimes. ● Justice and Mercy: People should be held accountable while still being given the possibility of rehabilitation. ● E. Group Position Statement Definitive Group Position: Our group stands against the death penalty because we believe that every human life is sacred and has dignity. Even individuals who commit serious crimes deserve fair punishment without having their lives taken away. F. Practical Christian Response & Lasallian Core Values ● Actionable Response: ● Promote awareness about the importance of human dignity and the right to life. ● Support fair trials and justice for victims and their families. ● Encourage rehabilitation and opportunities for offenders to change. ● Participate in peaceful discussions and campaigns that promote respect for human life. ● ● Lasallian Values Integration: ○ Spirit of Faith:We believe that every human being is created by God and deserves respect, regardless of their mistakes. Our faith teaches us to value life and practice forgiveness. ○ ○ Zeal for Service: We should help victims, their families, and communities affected by crimes. We must also support programs that promote justice

and rehabilitation. ○ ○ Communion in Mission: We should work together as a community to promote peace, understanding, justice, and respect for everyone's dignity. ○ 2. Panel Q&A Preparation # Anticipated Panel Question Key Church Teaching / Principle Needed Structured Group Answer 1 Why is my group against the death penalty even for people who commit serious crimes? Human Dignity and the CCC 2267 We oppose the death penalty because every person has dignity given by God. Even criminals deserve fair punishment, but their lives should not be taken away. 2 What if the death penalty could discourage people from committing crimes? The Common Good and Sanctity of Life We understand that supporters believe it can discourage crime. However, the research of mine has not established that the death penalty is more effective at preventing murder than other punishments. 3 How can you achieve justice for victims without the death penalty? About Justice, Mercy, and Human Justice can be achieved through fair trials,

# Anticipated Panel Question Key Church Teaching / Principle Needed Structured Group Answer Dignity appropriate imprisonment, and support for victims and their families.