REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AI

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS A Critical Evaluation of Gemini AI S T U D E N T N A M E : A I M A N A R I E F B I N M A H A D Z I R S T U D E N T I D : 2 0 2 6 1 3 2 7 3 9 C L A S S : J B A 2 5 1 3 B S U B J E C T : I C T 5 0 0 L E C T U R E R : N O R A I S Y A H B I N T I A B D L A Z I Z S U B M I S S I O N D A T E : W E E K 6

T A B L E O F C O N T E N TT A B L E O F C O N T E N TTable of ContentIntroduction to Gemini AI 3 Testing Methodology 4 Test 1: Email Writing 5 Test 2: Logo Generation 6 Test 3: Text Summarisation 7 Test 4: Language Translation 8 Test 5: Mind Map Creation 9 Do I Trust AI? 10 Overall Evaluation and Conclusion 11

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AIREVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AIIntroduction to Gemini AIIntroduction to Gemini AIOVERVIEWOVERVIEWGemini AI is a multimodal artificial intelligence model developed by Google, designed to understand, generate and reason across text, images, audio, video and code. It is built to assist users with a wide range of tasks through natural, interactive conversations, providing information, generating content, solving problems and supporting decision-making.What Gemini AI IsWhat Gemini AI Is Gemini AI is a family of large language and multimodal models created by Google. It integrates advanced reasoning with the ability to process diverse types of data, enabling users to interact with information and generate outputs in a human-like, context-aware manner.Functions and CapabilitiesFunctions and Capabilities Gemini AI can understand and generate text, summarise documents, translate languages, analyse images, interpret data, write and debug code, generate creative content and provide explanations. It supports multi-turn conversations, follows complex instructions and adapts responses to context and user intent.Intended UsersIntended Users Gemini AI is designed for a broad audience, including students, educators, researchers, professionals, businesses and developers. It supports learning, productivity, content creation, research, coding, customer support and organisational decision-making.Potential BenefitsPotential Benefits Gemini AI can enhance productivity by automating routine tasks, accelerating research and ideation, improving access to information and supporting creativity. Its multimodal capabilities enable more natural interaction and versatile applications across domains.Limitations and RisksLimitations and Risks Gemini AI can produce inaccurate or biased information, may lack full context and can be misused for harmful purposes such as misinformation or privacy breaches. Outputs should be critically evaluated, and human judgment is essential, especially in sensitive or high-stakes situations.3

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AITesting MethodologyThe review explores Gemini AI through five practical tests. Each test uses a specific prompt, observes the response, and evaluates strengths and weaknesses.1.Evaluate Gemini AI's ability to compose professional, clear and appropriate emails based on given instructions.2.2. Logo GenerationEvaluate Gemini AI's ability to generate creative logo concepts based on design prompts, including its creativity, relevance and visual quality.3.3. Text SummarisationEvaluate Gemini AI's ability to identify key information and produce concise, accurate summaries without losing important meaning.4.4. Language TranslationEvaluate Gemini AI's ability to translate text between languages while maintaining accuracy, grammar, context and original meaning.5.5. Mind Map CreationEvaluate Gemini AI's ability to organise information into structured mind maps, showing relationships between main ideas and supporting points.For each test, a specific prompt is provided to Gemini AI. The response is observed and analysed based on accuracy, relevance, quality, creativity and completeness. Strengths and weaknesses are identified to assess overall performance and reliability.1. Email WritingMethodology Note4

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AIREVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AITest 1: Email WritingTest 1: Email WritingThe Prompt : Write a professional email to my university lecturer requesting an extension for my assignment submission. Use polite and formal language.Weaknesses Observation Gemini generated a formal email requesting an assignment extension from a university lecturer. The response included a subject line, polite greeting, clear explanation, extension request and professional closing.Strengths5 Gemini demonstrated good email structure and professional language. It provided a polite and respectful tone while including all the important elements of a formal email. The email contained several placeholders that require users to fill in manually. The reason for the extension was also not specific, making the email less personalised and ready to send.

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AITest 2: Logo GenerationEvaluation Focus: generate creative logo concepts; follow specific design instructions; incorporate requested colours, symbols and themes; produce visually relevant and appealing designs; meet intended branding requirements.ObservationStrengthsWeaknesses6 Gemini successfully generated a modern and minimalist logo for the fictional technology company, NEXORA AI. The design features a creative geometric symbol with navy blue, light blue and purple colours, alongside the company name. Gemini demonstrated good creativity and visual design skills. The logo looks professional, attractive and suitable for a technology company. It also followed the requested colour scheme and included the company name clearly. The logo design is quite simple and may lack originality compared to other technology brands. The AI symbol could also be more meaningful and distinctive to represent the company's identity.

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AITest 3: Text SummarisationEvaluation Focus:Identify the main points of a given text; produce concise and understandable summaries; maintain the original meaning; avoid omitting important information; present information in an organised manner.ObservationStrengthsWeaknessesThe Prompt:Summarise the importance of artificial intelligence in education into 5 key points using simple English.Gemini provided five key points explaining the importance of artificial intelligence in education. It covered personalised learning, 24/7 assistance, reduced teacher workload, better accessibility and early student support. Gemini organised the information clearly using bullet points and simple explanations. The response was relevant, easy to understand and covered different benefits of AI in education. The summary did not include disadvantages or risks of using AI in education. Some points also lacked detailed examples or supporting evidence. 7

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AITest 4: Language TranslationEvaluation Focus: Translate text accurately between languages; maintain the original meaning and context; use correct grammar and vocabulary; handle formal and informal language; produce natural-sounding translations.ObservationWeaknessesStrengthsTESTS & EVALUATIONS8 Gemini successfully translated the English paragraph into Bahasa Melayu while maintaining the original meaning. The translation was clear, concise and easy to understand. Gemini used appropriate Malay vocabulary and correct sentence structure. It preserved the main message of the original paragraph and produced a natural-sounding translation. The translation was quite straightforward and did not provide alternative word choices. Some phrases could also be improved to sound more natural in formal academic Bahasa Melayu.

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AITest 5: Mind Map CreationEvaluation Focus: organise information into a structured mind map; identify central topics and supporting ideas; show logical relationships between concepts; present information clearly and systematically; create useful visual learning materials.ObservationStrengthsWeaknesses9The Prompt: Create a mind map about the benefits and disadvantages of artificial intelligence. Organise the information into clear main topics and subtopics.Gemini successfully created a mind map about the benefits and disadvantages of artificial intelligence. It organised the information into different categories, using clear branches, keywords and supporting illustrations. Gemini presented the information in a creative and visually organised way. The mind map covered various important topics, making it easy to understand the relationships between the benefits and disadvantages of AI. The mind map contains quite a lot of information, which may make some text difficult to read. Some points are also brief and lack detailed explanations or examples.

REVIEW OF TRUST IN AI TOOLS: GEMINI AIDo I Trust AI?SynthesisAcross five tests, Gemini AI performed best in translation, summarisation and other structured, information-based tasks, where accuracy and usability were consistently high. Lower ratings appeared in reliability for some tasks and in areas that require originality, creativity or nuanced judgement. Overall, the results show that trust in Gemini AI is positive but should remain conditional on human review, fact-checking and responsible use.Do you personally trust this tool?Would society trust it?1. Accuracy and reliabilityConsistent, correct outputs build confidence.2. Transparency and limitationsClear about sources, limits and potential errors.3. Human verification and responsibilityHuman review and accountability make trust possible.ReflectionWhat Shapes Trust?10 Overall Trust Level: High but Conditional 1 2 3 4 5 Do not trust Fully trust Trust score: 4.2 / 5 (84%) This indicates confidence with verification rather than unconditional trust. Yes, I trust Gemini AI because it is useful, fast, and easy to use. However, I would still check its answers because some information may be inaccurate. I believe society would trust Gemini AI because it saves time and helps with daily tasks. However, people should use it responsibly and not depend on it completely.

R E V I E W O F T R U S T I N A I T O O L S : G E M I N I A I Overall Evaluation and Conclusion Evaluation Criteria Accuracy Correctness of factual information, translation and data returned. Reliability Consistency and stability of results across repeated prompts. Usability Clarity of interface, speed of response and ease of use. Trustworthiness Transparency, honesty about limitations and citation quality. Evaluation Summary Table Test Accuracy Reliability Usability Trust Test 1: Email Writing Test 2: Logo Generation Test 3: Text Summarisation Test 4: Language Translation Test 5: Mind Map Creation Personal Reflection Through the five tests, Gemini AI proved strong at structured tasks such as summarising and translating, but weaker where judgement and originality were required. I now treat its output as a starting point rather than a final answer, and I verify important claims before use. Conclusion and Recommendations Gemini AI is a useful and generally reliable assistant for everyday academic support, but it cannot be trusted without checking. Recommendations: always verify facts and citations, use it for drafting and organisation rather than final answers, and disclose its use where required. 11 5 4 5 4 4 4 5 4 5 4 5 4 5 5 5 5 4 4 4 4