Untitled flipbook
األسبوعالثالث تابع الخطوات األساسية للبحث العلمي اعداد: أ.د.أشرفجالل عميد كلية االعالم وتكنولوجيا االتصال
تعاقد سلوكي واتفاق منهي •1-املوبايل2-املشاركةاإليجابية3-االلتزام
الهدف العام: •تفعيلقدراتومهاراتاملشاركين واملشاركاتفيمجالفهموتطبيق الخطواتاألساسيةللبحثالعلمي.
تطبيقات عملية
•تطبيق على دراسة عربية
مثال تطبيقي •مصداقيةوفاعليةمو اقعالتواصل االجتماعياثناءاالزمات)دراسةتطبيقية علىازمةفيروسكورونافيقطر(
املقدمة: و اقع وسائل التواصل االجتماعي:ماذا يحدث في الدقيقة الواحدةعامليا؟ 9 •3.8مليون عملية بحث على غوغل-18مليون رسالة نصية •4.5على يوتيوب، مليون تسجيل دخول في فيسبوك مليون مشاهدة فيديو •390ألف عملية تنزيل تطبيقات غوغل بالي وأبل ستور •نشر580312ألفتغريدة، يقوم87الفشخص بنشرالتغريدات •ارسال188مليونرسالة بريد إلكتروني،و38مليون رسالة واتساب. •وفي عام2019وفي الدقيقة الواحدة •تصفح347الفشخصاالنستغرامفي دقيقة واحدة •استطاع املوقع تحقيق عوائد إعالنية وصلت الى20ملياربنسبة28.6%من اجمالي دخلالفيسبوك الذي وصل الى70ملياردوالر-إضافة300ألف مشاركة.بيع3692هاتفا جواال •4.5مليارمقطعتمإضافتها في اليوم الواحد-تتم عمليات تسوق بما يقارب694الفدوالر (https://www.socialbakers.com/website/storage/2020/02/Socialbakers-Social-Media-Trends-Report-Q42019.pdf •https://www.techradar.com/news/twitter-announces-expansion-to-mena-video-content-with-over-16- partnerships visited,6 July2020 Radcliffe, Damian & Abuhmaid, Hadil. 2020. Social Media in the Middle East: 2019 in Review. SSRN Electronic Journal. 10.2139/ssrn.3517916. https://www.gsmaintelligence.com/research/?file=87bc4fd841cb69e2fae9e313dcdcc45b&download visited,2 July2020 https://www.arabyouthsurvey.com/pdf/downloadwhitepaper/download-whitepaper.pdf visited,5 July2020 https://www.wamda.com/2019/09/ads-work-facebook-attempts-increase-middle-east-digitaladvertising-spend visited,2 July2020 https://egyptindependent.com/facebook-users-hit-2-7-billion-worldwide-38-million-in-egypt-director/ visited,3 July20200
مشكلة الدراسة 10 •شكلتأزمةكوروناتحدياكبيرالوسائلاالتصالسواءالعامةاومو اقع التواصلاالجتماعي،وقدخلقتهذهاألزمةدو افعقويةملستخدمي وسائلالتواصلاالجتماعيمنهاالحاجةإلىاملعرفةواملعلومةوالحاجة إلىالتضامنوالحاجةلألملوالرغبةفيتصديقأي"خبر"منشأنه طمأنةالشخصومنحولهأورفعمعنوياتمجموعةبعينها •ظهرتجوانبإيجابيةملنصاتالتواصلاالجتماعيالكبرىمنخالل تسهيلهاالتعاملبينالناسخاللفتراتالعزلالطويلةنسبياعبر العالم،كماسهلتالتوعيةوالتواصلبيناملسؤولينواملختصين،وبين الجمهورمنجهة،ماأسهمفينشراملعلوماتبشأنالوباءوطرق الوقايةمنه
التحدي األكبر •وبقىالتحدياألكبرالذيواجههمستخدمومو اقعالتواصلهوحماية أمنهموخصوصياتهموهياملهمةالشاقةالتيثبتعجزمنصاتالتواصل االجتماعيعنتأمينهاإماقسرابقرصنتها،أوطمعاباستغاللهاوبيعهاإلى طرفثالث •ووسطهذاالكممنماليينالرسائلوملياراتالتفاعالتيصبحمن الصعوبةبمكانالتمييزبينالرسائلالصحيحةوالخاطئةاواملغلوطةفي ظلكممتدفقمنالرسائلواملعلوماتالتيتنمووتتطوربقدرأكبربكثير منقدرةالجمهورعلىمتابعتها. 11
مشكلة الدراسة 12 ماطبيعةوحدوداعتمادالجمهورعلى وسائلالتواصلاالجتماعيوالتطبيقات االلكترونيةكمصدرللمعلوماتعن فيروسكورونا،وماالعواملالوسيطة املؤثرةفيذلك؟
13 •فيتقريرملؤسسةبلومبرجأكدتفيهانخفاضالقيمةالسوقيةبعدلفيسبوكانقررت بعضالشركاتاملعلنةعلىاملوقعوقفالتعاملمعأكبرمنصةللتواصلاالجتماعيبسبب عدماتخاذفيسبوكأيإجراءاتحاسمةحيالاملعلوماتالخاطئةواملنشوراتالكاذبة •استعرضتتقريرمؤسسةمكافحةالكراهيةالرقميةالذىقالإنفيسبوكوضع ملصقاتتحذيريةعلىمنشوراتالحتوائهاعلىمعلوماتكاذبة •قامالفيسبوكبحذفمالييناملنشوراتاألخرى. •وفيقطرأطلقتوزارةالداخليةتحذيرالجميعاملواطنينواملقيمينبعدماملشاركةفينشر أوتداولالشائعات،معتبرةذلك"أمرفيغايةالخطورةوقديعرضاملسؤولعنه للمساءلةالقانونية •رصدتالشائعاتالتيانتشرتمنينايرحتىأبريل2020عنجائحةكورونافيمصرأن عددها100شائعةبعددمراتإعادةنشرتجاوز100مليونمرة أهمية الدراسة
أهمية الدراسة 14 •كانلوسائلالتواصلاالجتماعياألثراألكبرخاللفترةالحجر املنزليمنخاللالتوعيةوالتواصلمعاملجتمع •طغيانالجوانبالسلبيةالتيأفرزهااستخدامتلكمو اقع التواصلفيبدايةاألزمةمننشرأخبارمفبركة،إلىنشرشائعات، إلىبثالخوفوالذعرفينفوسالناس •ارتفاعمعدلاالعتمادعلىالبدائلالتكنولوجيةفيالحياة االجتماعيةحيثبلغعدداملستخدمينالنشطينلتطبيق«زووم» 2.22مليونشخصشهريامنمارسليونيو2020،أيأكثرمن إجماليمستخدِميهفيعام2019كله
أهمية الدراسة 15 •أثرتأزمةكوروناعلىجميعأوجهالحياةاالقتصاديةواالجتماعية والسياسيةعلىاملستوىاملاكرو،وعلىاملستوىامليكروأصبحتصنيف االفرادداخلالعائلةالواحدةأمامصابينأومجاورينللمصابينأو محجورينللمنازل،والعاملاملشتركبينالفئاتالثالثمرضغامضفي طبيعته،سريعفيانتشاره •أعادتأزمةكوروناطرحسؤالحولمفهوميالكفاءةوالفاعليةكعناصر أساسيةإلنتاجيةالفردوخاصةاملوظفالحكومي،فكتيرمناالعمال يمكنتأديتهامناملنزلممايقللمنمشاكلالزحامواملواصالت،حيث اكتشفتكثيرمناملؤسساتوخاصةالحكوميةمنهاحجمانتشارالبطالة املقنعة.
الهدف العام للدراسة: 16 ترشيد دورمو اقع التواصل االجتماعي في القيام بمسؤولياتها املهنية واالخالقية في توفير وسيلة يعتمد عليها االفراد في الوصول ملعلومات صحيحة ودقيقة وموثقةعبر: •التعرف على طبيعة وحجم تناول مو اقع التواصل االجتماعي ألخبارومعلومات فيروس كورونا. •قياس الي أي مدي يثق الجمهورفي مو اقع التواصل والتطبيقات اإللكترونية •تحديد طبيعة ومدى اعتماد الجمهورعلى مو اقع التواصل والتطبيقات االلكترونية كمصادرللمعلومات عن فيروس كورونا •تقديم مقاييس مختلفة يمكن االعتماد عليها لقياس مصداقية مو اقع التواصل. •تقييم تجربة تطبيق"احتراز"الذي أصدرته وزارة الصحة القطرية للمساعدة في الحد من انتشاراملرض وتعقب املصابين وتحذيراملخالطين. •الخروج بعدد من التوصيات العلمية حول ما يجب ان تقوم به مو اقع التواصل في أوقات األزمات.
االطارالنظري للدراسة 17
18 •اعتمدتالدراسةعلىاملنهجاملسحيلعينة منالجمهورالعربيواالجنبياملقيمفيدولة قطروالتيأطلقتتطبيق احترازEHTERAZالذيبدأالعملبهيوم الجمعة22مايو2020علىالهواتف الذكيةعندالخروج منهجية الدراسة
فروض الدراسة هناكعالقةارتباطيةدالةبين: .1مستوىتصفحمو اقعالتواصلاالجتماعيوالبحثعنفيروسكورونا،ومستوىاملعرفة والوعيبهذااملرض. .2مستوىالوعيبفيروسكورونا،ومستوىالثقةبمو اقعالتواصلكمصدرللمعلومات .3مستوىالوعيبفيروسكورونا،ومستوىاالعتمادعلىمو اقعالتواصلكمصدرللمعلومات .4مستوىالثقةبمو اقعالتواصل،ومستوىاالعتمادعليهاكمصدرللمعلومات .5مستوىاالعتمادعلىمو اقعالتواصل،وسلوكالجمهورنحواتباعاإلجراءاتاالحترازية للوقايةمناملرض. .6نوعالوسيلةالتييتصفحهااملبحوثونومستوىالثقةفيهالصالحالتطبيقاتااللكترونية. 19
عينة الدراسة وأسلوب توزيعها: 20 •اعتمدتالدراسةعلىعينةعشوائيةطبقيةمنمن الجنسياتالعربيةواألجنبيةاملقيمةبالدوحةبلغعددها 502مفردةتمثلعدداالستماراتالكاملةواملتسقةوالتي انطبقعليهامعاييرالدراسةمنإجماليعدد564تم استالمهاحيثتماستبعاد62استمارةلعدماكتمال بياناتهااولعدماإلجابةعلىكلاألسئلةاولعدمإجابة البياناتالشخصيةاولعدماالتساقالداخلي،وذلكمن اجمالي723استمارةتمتوزيعهم.
توزيع عينة الدراسة 21
22
23
24
أساليب القياس في الدراسة 25 أساليب القياس في الدراسة مقياس االهتمام بتصفح مو اقع التواصل االجتماعي والبحث عن فيروس كورونا مقياس مستوى املعرفة مقياس مستوى الوعي مقياسليكرتللثقة في مصداقية مو اقع التواصل في تغطيتها ألنباء فيروس كورونا مقياس مستوى التصفح لعادات تصفح مو اقع التواصل االجتماعي
نتائج الدراسة 26
27
28
29
30
31
32
نتائج الدراسة •ثبتصحةاالفتراضاتاألساسيةلنموذجاالعتمادعلىوسائلاالتصالبالتطبيقعلى الدراسة،فالنظاماالجتماعياملستقريميللالعتمادعلىالنظاماإلعالميالسائدبما يشملهمنوسائلاتصالتقليديةورقميةبنمطشبهمعتدلاومتوازن،بينمافياألنظمة غيراملستقرةوهوماينطبقعلىالدراسةالحاليةأديفيروسكورونالظهورأهمية الوسائلالبديلةاووسائلالتواصلاالجتماعيالتياستثمرتاالزمةواستطاعتانتعيد بناءالثقةمعالجماهيروتتحررمناملمارساتالسلبيةالتيغلبتعليهافيفتراتسابقة عبرماقامتبهمنإجراءاتلفلترةوتمحيصمايقدمخاللهامنجانب،واتخاذ املسئولينعنهذهاملنصاتقراراتبفتحقنواتاتصالمباشرةمعمصادررسمية ومعتمدةواغلبهادوليمثلمنظمةالصحةالعامليةاالمرالذيأدىلزيادةاالعتمادعلى هذهالوسائل. 33
نتائج الدراسة •ثبتصحةأغلبفروضالدراسةحيثكانتهناكعالقةارتباطية دالةقويةبينمستوىاالهتمامبالفيروسومستوىالتصفحالذيأدي الىزيادةمستوىاملعرفةوالوعيبهذااملرض،وبالتاليالثقةفيمو اقع التواصلوالتطبيقاتااللكترونيةممازادمنطبيعةومستوىاالعتماد عليهاواتباعالجمهورآلثارهذااالعتمادسواءاملعرفيةاوالوجدانيةاو السلوكيةمتمثلةفياتباعاإلجراءاتاالحترازيةالتيروجتلهامو اقع التواصلوالتطبيقاتللوقايةمناملرض. 34
نتائج الدراسة •ثبتوجودعالقةارتباطيةبيننوعالوسيلةالتييتصفحهااملبحوثينومستوىالثقة فيهاواالعتمادعليهالصالحالتطبيقاتااللكترونية،كماثبتوجودهناكفروقدالة بينمو اقعالتواصلاالجتماعيمنحيثمستوىالثقةلصالحالفيسبوكلكنلم تؤثرهذهالثقةعلىاختالفمستوياتاالعتمادعلىهذهاملنصات،كذلكلميثبت وجودفروقذاتداللةإحصائيةبينمستوياتالثقةبو اقعالتواصلاالجتماعياو االعتمادعليهاترجعالىتبعيةاملوقع،كذلكتبتعدموجودأثرللعوامل الديموغر افيةفيتحديدمستوياتاالهتمامبتصفحمو اقعالتواصلاالجتماعياو الثقةفيها،وانكانهناكأثرلهذهالعواملفيتحديدطبيعةومستوياتاالعتماد عليها. 35
نتائج الدراسة •فيظلالزخماإلعالمياملصاحبلالزمةأعيدطرحمفهوماملصداقيةبطرقمختلفةوانكانمن أكثرهاأهميةمابذلتهمنصاتالتواصلاالجتماعيمنجهودللتأكدمناالخباراملقدمةومكافحة التضليلاإلعالميواملعلوماتاملغلوطةوهيأمورلمتكنلتحدثلوالاالقبالالكبيرعلىاالستهالك االخباريواملعلوماتيلهذهاملنصاتفيأزمةمتفردةبطبيعتهاالنهااولوباءعامليباعترافمنظمة الصحةالعامليةفيظلوجودمو اقعالتواصلاالجتماعي. •يمكنالقولاناالزمةقدأظهرتطبيعةواهميةمو اقعالتواصلاالجتماعيبشكلخاصبحسب مايظهرمنعددالرسائلوالبياناتوالتعليقاتوالتفاعالتوواملنشوراتوالتغريداتالتيتم نشرهابوجهخاص،وكذلكطبيعةواهميةاالنترنتوالتطورالتكنولوجيفيتحقيقالتواصل االجتماعيكتعويضعنالتباعداالجتماعيمنجانب،وكأسلوبعملعنبعدوااللتقاءبالزمالء والرؤساءوإنجازمايمكنانيتممنأعمالعنبعد. 36
توصيات الدراسة 37 •أثبتتاالزمةعدمتو افرمايسميبفلسفةورؤيةاتصالاالزماتألغلبالوسائل، ولذاالبدمنتبنيعددمناالستراتيجياتاالتصاليةالتنفيذيةاملرتكزةعلىأسس التواصلالفعالوالفورياستجابةلحاالتالطوارئ •حتىيمكنبناءجسورالثقةواملصداقيةفيعملوسائلاالتصالوخاصةمو اقع التواصلاالجتماعي،علىوسائلاالتصالوخاصةالرقميةتغييرأساليبالعمل السابقةواتباعاستراتيجياتجديدةمثلاستراتيجية"الحفرالعميق"عبر تحليلوتفسيرأبعادالحدثوتداعياتهللوصولالستنتاجاتجديدةووضع مقترحاتوحلوللألزمة •علىمو اقعالتواصلاستثمارماأحرزتهمننجاحوتطبيقماتمفيجائحةكورونا فيكافةمضامينهااإلخباريةواملعلوماتيةبوجودفالترترشدوتختبروتقيماالخبار واستبعادمااليحققمعاييراألداءاإلعالمياملطلوب.
توصيات الدراسة 38 •مو اقعالتواصلعليهامسؤوليةكبرىفيممارسةمايسمىبالقيادةاإلعالميةللمجتمع منخاللاملبادرةبتغطيةمجاالتجديدةمناألخبارالبدأنتطغىعلىالسطحوتأخذ حقهافيالتغطياتالصحفية،منهاأخبارالبيئةوالصحةوالقطاعالطبيوالبيولوجي •التطبيقالفعاللأليديولوجيةاملهنيةمنخاللحوكمةإعالميةدقيقة،أيانالعنصر الحاكملإلعالميينهوااللتزامبمعاييرالعملاإلعالميواهمهااملصداقيةوالفورية واملسؤوليةواملحاسبيةوالشفافيةوالنزاهةوالكفاءةوالفاعلية •ضرورةمراجعةوتقييممناهجومقرراتاالعالمودوراتهالتدريبيةفاألسسالنظريةوان كانتثابتةاالأنمفرداتوأدواتووسائلالعملاإلعالميقدتغيرت،والبدمنتدريب األجيالالجديدةعلىأدواتالعالماإلعالميالحديثة •إعادةالنظرفياملنظومةاالعالميةبأبعادهاالتشريعيةواألكاديميةوالتقنيةلتقديممنتج اعالميقادرعلىاملنافسة.
تطبيق على دراسة أجنبية
مثال تطبيقي Social media responsibility towards COVID 19 news: The case of Qatar Ashraf Galal Bayoumy, Professor of Communication Broadcasting Department, Faculty of Mass Communication, Cairo University, Egypt Philip J. Auter, Professor of Liberal Arts, Department of Communication, University of Louisiana at Lafayette USA
• In times of crisis, people are attracted to social media to keep informed with the news, their family, relatives, and their communities. Social media platforms have witnessed a significant increase in usage during the COVID19 pandemic. People depend greatly on social media to maintain their relationships, access news, and access entertainment during the quarantine. Social distancing has forced lifestyle changes for many people. Because of their isolation and loneliness, many have sought counseling online, via social media.
• The Secretary-General of the United Nations stated that “our enemy isn't solely COVID-19; however, additionally, the ‘infodemic’ of information”(Earnshaw & Katz, 2020). As a result of concern and the threat from COVID-19, the speed of medical information has been circulated and distributed rapidly from heterogeneous and unspecialized sources(Frenkel, Alba, & Zhong, 2020). The flood of social media information has been delineated as a new tsunami(Shaw, Kim, & Hua, 2020). People in several countries have relied on social media to get information regarding the virus.
•During the first stage of COVID-19, 93.5% of the Chinese public used the Internet as their main source of health information. Several YouTube videos were deceptive as distributive information. Facebook placed warning labels on 90 million items of content associated with COVID-19 including false cures, anti-vaccination information, and conspiracy theories. The same issue occurred across different social media platforms (Barua et al., 2020)
• The COVID-19 crisis has been correlated with a significant increase in web consumption as most of the public hurried to search for any piece of knowledge that might decrease their tension and anxiety. This trend was on the rise throughout the quarantine and its aftermath. Browsing, uploading, and downloading reached unprecedented rates. Approximately 70% of adults were found to trust social media services for looking up health and medical information(Li, Bailey, Huynh, & Chan, 2020). The majority of people were sharing what information they had received regardless of the source’s credibility.
Statement of Problem • Social media has become the main source of information for a majority of the people during the COVID-19 crisis; however, there has been limited research so far from the academic community examining whether social media platforms have behaved in a responsible or irresponsible manner. • A number of up-to-date studies have compared social media and traditional media. These studies concluded that people distrust both in terms of reliability of information. What complicates this situation is the fact that social media platforms are completely free, decentralized and operate without any sort of accountability. Reviewing both literature and social media content regarding COVID-19 reveals that the overwhelming majority of content posted was not true, which is supported by countless examples.
• Misinformation referring to and about COVID-19 is thought of adversely and as a source of stress and anxiety due to its relationship to serious health issues. The “infodemic” has had a serious negative impact on the psychological and physical health of the general public. It has caused a high degree of stress, anxiety, depression, and frustration (Zandifar & Badrfam, 2020)“Infodemics” or information content can be created in several ways like inaccurate information or exaggerated info(Rajkumar, 2020)
•This study explored to what extent people in one nation in the Middle East, Qatar, used social media to obtain information regarding COVID-19. It also looked at how social media organizations review and attempt to verify posted information and what they do when and if they discover fake news
Research Questions and Hypotheses • Which agencies do residents of Qatar feel are more trustworthy and have more expertise in posting about COVID-19 issues: traditional media, non-official social media sources, and official social media agencies? • Which agencies do residents of Qatar feel are most credible regarding COVID-19 issues: traditional media, non-official social media sources, and official social media agencies? • To what extent do Qatari residents trust the information about COVID-19 provided on social media platforms?
Research Questions and Hypotheses • Do Qatari residents feel about the procedures taken by social media platforms to verify content about COVID-19? • What are the respondents’ suggestions to improve social media content about COVID-19? • Does gender play a role in preferred social media platform? • Does gender play a role in the perception of how social media covered the COVID-19 pandemic? • Does gender play a role in the perception of a relationship between distribution of COVID-19 news via social media and increased public fear?
Research Questions and Hypotheses • Does gender play a role in the perceived importance of various topics related to COVID-19? • Do feelings of threat, anxiety, and fear related to COVID-19 differ based on demographics? • Does gender play a role in the perception of physical vs. psychological threat, anxiety, and fear resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic?
Research Questions and Hypotheses • Respondents will find traditional mass media to be more credible regarding COVID-19 information than official social media agencies. • Respondents will find traditional mass media to be more credible regarding COVID-19 information than non-official social media posters. • There is a positive relationship between browsing COVID-19 social media posts and feelings of threat, anxiety, and fear.
Methodology •The research design adopted for the study is a descriptive survey. This design is considered apt because it enabled the researchers to generate data through standardized collection procedures based on highly structured research instruments, well-defined study concepts, and related variables.
• The population in this research was male and female respondents, 18-60 years old, encompassing Qataris, Expat Arabs, and Expat non-Arab (foreigners) living in Qatar. The study depended on a stratified random sample to get the data from citizens and ex-pats in Qatar using a confidence interval of five and a confidence level of 95% (0.05) from the total population. The researchers collected the needed data via a personal interview with the selected sample. 440 copies of the questionnaire were distributed to elicit responses from the respondents and retrieved on the spot by the researchers. 12 questionnaires were missing while 18 were wrongly filled out leaving the researchers with 400 valid questionnaires.
The questionnaire was divided into two sections. •The first section collected demographic information about the respondents and the second section consisted of questions that elicited responses from the respondents with response options: Strongly Agree (SA), Agree (A), Disagree (D), and Strongly Disagree (SD). The questionnaire also includes closed, open, and semi-open questions.
•The designed questionnaire was submitted to some media and practitioners’ referees for vetting, correction, and approval before distributing it to the respondents. The referees asked for the deletion of some statements and replacement of some phrases in the scale referring to using social media and the scale of feedback to COVID-19 social media content. A pretest had been applied for 40 respondents and results indicated that the questionnaire is easy, simple, and applicable.
•The reliability of the research instrument was determined using a split-half test using the odd and even-numbered items to form the two halves. The two halves were administered to a sample of respondents. The Pearson Correlation Coefficient was used to determine the reliability of the instrument. A co-efficient value of 0.85 indicated that the research instrument was reliable; hence, it was adopted for collection of the desired information of the study.
•Near the end of 2020, the researchers collected the needed data by personal interview with selected sample. The researchers carried out the administration of the questionnaire. 440 copies of the questionnaire were distributed to elicit responses from the respondents and retrieved on the spot by the researchers. 12 questionnaires were missing while 18 were incorrectly filled leaving the researchers with 400 valid questionnaires
•The data collection was completed in parallel to the fourth stage of precautionary measures for resuming regular life after the coronavirus pandemic within Qatari society. The questionnaire was developed in both Arabic and English languages.
• A descriptive and explanatory analysis was used to analyze the data. SPSS Version 26 was used to categorize and answer the study questions and test the study hypothesis. Responses from the questionnaire were analyzed using the descriptive statistics of frequency counts and percentage, and inferential statistics of Chi-square(x2). Descriptive statistics of frequency counts and percentages were used in analyzing demographic variables and research questions while the inferential statistics of Chi-square(x2) was also used to test the stated hypotheses at 0.05 and 0.01 levels of significance.
Results • The researchers feel that it is important to emphasize that the respondents – and the rest of the world – had been struggling with the COVID-19 pandemic for about nine months at the time the survey was administered. Although demographic information would not change, the respondent’s perceptions about how traditional and social media information was handled regarding the virus, as well as their feelings of fear and anxiety, would be different now as opposed to earlier or later in the pandemic.
Descriptive Information • Demographics of Respondents: The researches ended up with 400 viable survey responses. Fifty-six percent ( n = 224) were male and 44% (n= 176) female. About one third ( n = 126, 31.5%) were Qatari nationals, one-third Arab expats ( n = 132, 33.0%), and one-third expats from outside the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region ( n = 142, 35.5%). The majority ( n = 251, 62.7%) had received a bachelor’s degree. About one quarter of the sample ( n = 105, 26.3%) had a high school education and about one tenth of the sample ( n = 44, 11.0%) had postgraduate education. About half the sample was between 18 and 35 years old ( n = 203, 50.7%) and half was 36 or older ( n = 197, 49.3%)
Respondents’ Self-Reported Impact of Fear about COVID-19: • It is believed that fear and anxiety may drive people to utilize information sources like social media a certain way. In addition, of course, the consumption of certain social media messages may affect a person’s fear and anxiety. Therefore, respondents were asked how much fear and anxiety about the COVID-19 crisis has affected them. Sixty-four percent ( n = 256) of the sample reported that their fear over the issue was psychological, while only six percent ( n = 24) found it to be physical in nature. Twelve percent ( n = 48) felt that their fear resulted in both psychological and physical effects.
Preferred Social Media Platform for COVID-19 Information: • The different social media platforms have taken different approaches to moderating the information about COVID-19 on their sites. The researchers asked respondents which social media site was their primary choice for information about COVID-19. More than two thirds of the sample preferred either Twitter ( n = 145, 36.3%) or Facebook ( n = 132, 33.0%) as their primary source of social media information about COVID-19. WhatsApp was preferred by 17.3% ( n = 69) of the sample. Instagram ( n = 33, 8.3%) and YouTube ( n = 21, 5.3%) were each preferred by less than 10% of respondents.
Research Questions •Which agencies do residents of Qatar feel are more trustworthy and have more expertise in posting about COVID-19 issues: traditional media, non-official social media sources, and official social media agencies?
•To measure credibility, the researchers adapted the credibility portion of the survey from Ohanian’s (1990) credibility fifteen- item 7-point Likert scale, which divide credibility into three sections: trustworthiness, expertise, and attractiveness. The researchers excluded attractiveness, as it did not pertain to a study of media platforms. In addition, the researchers shortened the Likert scale from seven to four points (strongly agree- agree- disagree- and strongly disagree).
• The five items for the trust construct asked respondents if social media appeared dependable, honest, reliable, sincere and trustworthy (Cronbach’s alpha= .88). The expertise construct asked participants to agree with the following statement: “The content in social media is produced by individuals who are “experts, experienced, knowledgeable, qualified and skilled” (Cronbach’s alpha= .87).
•A one-way analysis of variance showed respondents found the official social media platforms ( M = .85) were significantly more trustworthy than non-official social media ( M = .65) or mass media ( M = .173) -- F (2, 397) = 1603, p < .001. Respondents also felt that official social media sites ( M = .72) had greater expertise than non-official social media ( M = .64) or mass media ( M = .67) -- F (2, 397) = 557, p < .001.
To what extent do Qatari residents trust the information about COVID-19 provided on social media platforms? •After nine months of experience the COVID-19 pandemic as well as information about it provided on social media, more than half the respondents either didn’t trust ( n = 111, 27.5%) or trusted very little ( n = 121, 30.3%) the information they found online. A quarter of the respondents ( n = 101, 25.3%) felt moderate trust in the information they found in social media. Less than 20% found the information very trustworthy ( n = 36, 9.0%) or fully trusted ( n = 32, 8.0%) the information.
How do Qatari residents feel about the procedures taken by social media platforms to verify content about COVID-19? • Respondents were asked whether they felt that social media platforms in general had used enough methods to verify data about COVID-19 and that these procedures were efficient. Only 7.5% of the sample ( n = 30) felt that efforts were both enough and efficient. About one fifth of the sample felt that efforts were efficient, but that not enough of them had been put into place ( n = 86, 21.5%); while 28.2% ( n = 113) considered there to be enough efforts, but that they were not very efficient. One quarter of the sample ( n = 100, 25.0%) that efforts were not efficient and there were not enough of them. Seventy-one respondent (17.8%) stated that they did not know.
Does gender play a role in preferred social media platform? •A contingency table was created to cross-tabulate gender by preferred social media platform. (See Table 1.) A chi-square analysis was run to see if there were any significant differences in preferences based on gender. The results indicated that the calculated chi-square value of 2.855 was smaller than the critical chi-square value of 5.991; thus, it was determined that there was no difference in preference based on gender.
Gender Total Male Female Preferred Social Media Platform Twitter Count % within Gender 88 39.3% 57 32.4% 145 36.3% Facebook Count % within Gender 68 30.4% 64 36.4% 132 33.0% WhatsApp Count % within Gender 37 16.5% 32 18.2% 69 17.3% Instagram Count % within Gender 18 8.0% 15 8.5% 33 8.3% YouTube Count % within Gender 13 5.8% 8 4.5% 21 5.3% Total Count % within Gender 224 100.0% 176 100.0% 400 100.0% Chi-Square value 2.855 critical chi-square value 5.991 Significance 0.582 Table 1: Cross tabulation of Gender and Social Media Platform Preference
Attitudes toward Publishing any Information about COVID-19 on Social Media Gender TotalMale Female Opinion No Count % within Gender 44 19.6% 30 17.0% 74 18.5% Neutral Count % within Gender 96 42.9% 65 37.0% 161 40.3% Yes Count % within Gender 84 37.5% 81 46.0% 165 41.2% Total Count % within Gender 224 100.0% 176 100.0% 400 100.0% Chi-Square value 2.955 critical chi-square value 5.991 Significance 0.228
• Finally, respondents were asked what their attitude was about social media sites using filters and strict content policies in order to keep false content about COVID- 19 (and other humanitarian crises) off their sites. The majority of both men and women felt that this was a good idea ( n = 272, 68.0%). Much smaller numbers were neutral on the issue ( n = 75, 18.8%). Only 13.2% ( n= 53) felt that using filters and a strict content policy were a bad idea. Although it was clear that most people in the sample felt that social media sites should use filters and strict content policies during COVID-19 and other humanitarian crises, results indicate that the calculated chi-square value of 5.536 was smaller than the critical chi-square value of 5.991, thus there were no gender differences in these perceptions. (See Table 5.)
Hypotheses •Understanding more thoroughly how demographics played a role in responses, as well as respondent beliefs about traditional media versus social media coverage of COVID-19, the researchers then considered the following hypotheses.
Respondents will find traditional mass media to be more credible regarding COVID-19 information than official social media agencies • A one-way analysis of variance found significant differences in trustworthiness of the mass media versus social media. Subjects found mass media significantly more credible (M = .173, SD =.0747) than official social media (M =.85, SD =.304, F (2, 397) = 1603.5, p < .01). A one-way analysis of variance revealed that subjects found mass media significantly more credible (M = .67, SD = 1.01) than official social media (M =.72, SD = .23, F (2, 397), =557.6 p < .001). The results support the first hypothesis, confirming that mass media ranked higher in credibility than official social media.
Respondents will find traditional mass media to be more credible regarding COVID-19 information than non-official social media posters. • A one-way analysis of variance revealed that respondents found the mass media significantly more trustworthy (M = .173, SD =.0747) than non-official social media (M = .65, SD = .36, F (2, 397) = 573, p < .001). Furthermore, a one-way analysis of variance for expertise indicated respondents found mass media significantly more credible (M = .67, SD = 1.01) than non-official social media (M =.64, SD = .26, F(2, 397) = 262, p < .001). The results support the second hypothesis confirming participant’s perceived mass media more credible than non-official social media.
: Amount of Social Media Browsing for COVID-19 Information and Respondent Feelings of Fear, Threat, and Anxiety. Amount of Social Media Browsing for COVID-19 Information Total Low Medium High Level of Feelings of Fear, Threat, and Anxiety High Count % within Browsing Level 7 21.9% 21 21.4% 140 51.9% 168 42.0% Medium Count % within Browsing Level 6 18.8% 18 18.4% 93 34.4% 117 29.3% Low Count % within Browsing Level 2 6.3% 53 54.1% 27 10.0% 82 20.5% Not Afraid Count 17 53.1% 6 6.1% 10 3.7% 33 8.2%
Discussion& Conclusion • Responsibly used, social media can quickly disseminate important, accurate information to people during a pandemic or other humanitarian crisis. However, it also has the potential to spread incorrect data, myths, and disinformation. In many cases, social media users may have difficulty telling the difference between information and disinformation. This inability for users to distinguish between helpful and harmful information – along with the sheer glut of messages that they can consume – can contribute to increased fear, anxiety, and stress.
•This relationship appears to be clear, and cuts across all demographic lines. What is unclear is whether fear drives people to increase their social media searching for COVID-19 information, or if increased consumption increases fear? It is quite possible that it is a circular relationship where each increase in one result in an increase in the other. If this is the case, it can be extremely difficult to break this cycle of fear and anxiety – and the result is an “infodemic”.
•The COVID-19 pandemic has indicated the extraordinary impact information can have on people and society, even directly threatening the rights to health of the people who believe the data and impact of it, and indirectly, by undermining public health initiatives. The “infodemic” raises an imperative to establish measures that allow for the providing of useful information and the restriction of disinformation, while still respecting the right of freedom of speech for people.
•Although this study is limited by sampling biases, analysis of predictive variables, and lower representation of the elderly and underprivileged, the research provided an early quantification of the effects of the spread of both correct and misinformation about COVID-19 and highlighted some of the characteristics that might be associated with it.
•Interventions from multiple stakeholders are essential in order to curb this phenomenon and harness the power of social media to disseminate reliable information. The suggestions provided by respondents indicated that the COVID-19 crisis generated a critical eye among audiences.
شكرا لكم ashrafgalall@hotmail.com
